The Ministry of Labour has published a draft text for the transposition of the EU Platform Work Directive, which is open to responses from the public until 19 November.
Article 6 of the text proposes a legal presumption of employment when “the totality of the facts established indicates the exercise of direction and control”. The wording “totality of the facts” means that all criteria proposed by the government have to be met to trigger the presumption. The criteria includes six points:
“a) the obligation of the person performing work on a platform not to use subcontractors or substitutes to provide the services that he has undertaken to offer for the platform,
“b) the obligation of the person performing work on a platform to undertake the execution of the specific projects proposed to him by the platform, without having the right to reject the projects,
“c) the obligation of the person performing work on a platform to accept the minimum or maximum number of projects he undertakes, which may vary, depending on the needs of the platform,
“d) the obligation of the person performing work on a platform not to provide his services to any third party or not to perform work for any third party, including competitors of the platform,
“e) the imposition of disciplinary sanctions by the platform on persons performing work on it,
“f) the determination by the platform of a maximum number of projects and a maximum remuneration for the provision of services by persons performing work on it for a specific period of time, subject to compliance with the platforms’ health and safety obligations.”
This creates a very high bar for a person performing platform work to trigger the presumption.
Other aspects of the draft proposal include that there is no administrative procedure to trigger the presumption, platform workers must go through a judicial hearing, and there is no collective mechanism for employment re-classification, with workers having to take cases one-by-one.
The proposal does include joint and several liability between intermediaries and digital labour platforms, but only for the obligations of the proposed law not labour issues more broadly.
Supporting measures include that when a court has verified that a presumption of employment exists on a digital labour platform that the labour inspectorate should establish control measures in relation to that platform.
Article 13 applies health and safety requirements on digital labour platforms to all persons performing platform work, regardless if they are an employee of the platform or not.
The fines which are applicable to GDPR are also applicable to breaches of the algorithmic management rights contained in this draft proposal.
